Preface
This monograph is one of three in a series of literature reviews focusing on
topics that influence school change. These are:
These monographs are part of SEDL's Leadership for Change Project. This
project's goal is to promote leadership and facilitate change among education
professionals to foster systems and schools that are structured to increase
achievement for all students, especially those at risk. The project hopes to
inform practitioners and policy makers about the need for attention to the
change process and the factors that will enhance the potential for successful
change efforts.
As noted this project pays with particular attention to students characterized
as at risk of failing in or dropping out of school. The Méndez-Morse and
Boyd reviews provide insights relative to leader characteristics and
contextual variables especially significant in addressing school change for
the benefit of at-risk students. Méndez-Morse suggests that effective
leaders possess particular sensitivity to the needs of less successful
learners, a characteristic that helps them make sound judgments about
potentially powerful programs to introduce and implement in the school. The
paper reports about other leader characteristics as well.
Boyd maintains that leaders need special understanding of the contextual
factors that impinge on at-risk students, on staff and on their school in
order to plan change with staff, parents, and community. Boyd enumerates
environmental and cultural factors that constitute the school's context.
Without accurate perceptions about the environmental and cultural factors that
interact with students and staff in at-risk settings, successful change in
these sites may not result.
Whether in sites of high ethnic/minority populations, in settings of language
deficient students, in schools where children come from poverty level,
one-parent families -- or from middle-class suburbia -- the strategies that
leaders use to bring about change are generic. School leaders may shape their
actions and behaviors to their own personal characteristics and belief
systems, and deliver them in ways that account for the cultural and
environmental factors of the staff, school, and community. But their
strategies, operationalized by their actions and behaviors, remain consistent,
as revealed by the research conducted in widely varying school sites.
For example, a leader in an economically disadvantaged school may introduce
the idea of school change in a way different from the leader who introduces
improvement to an economically comfortable school with a high number of merit
scholars. But in either case, a key strategy for initiating change is
development of a vision of improved effectiveness.
This review identifies strategies generically required for successful change
in any setting. However, it is not a how-to-do-it document. Training and
development in these strategies may be found in various professional
development programs, and the Leadership for Change Project is producing some
resources. For example, see Tompkins, The Change Exchange: A Compendium of
Resources. Further, the project is creating a set of growth and development
materials and activities to support leaders' knowledge, understanding, and
skills in facilitating change. These materials titled, Leadership Development
for Facilitating Change, will be available Spring, 1993. In addition, project
staff produce short, four to ten page quarterly briefing papers on Issues
...about Change to increase attention on and awareness about change
leadership.
This paper includes an examination of approaches to change articulated in the
1960s and 1970s and cites a typically missing factor in these early approaches
-- the human interface or change facilitator. A second section of the paper
focuses on the change facilitating strategies of principals and their
leadership teams as documented in the 1980s, and also on strategies of
superintendents that are parallel at the district level to those at the school
level. In the final section, material about leadership for change needed for
restructuring and systemic change in the 1990s is reported -- for the most
part speculative, since little research has to date been conducted or reported
on the "restructuring" leader.
This paper has been produced in honor of those school leaders who have
energetically and enthusiastically committed themselves to improving schools,
and in the hope that the information reported about these leaders will be
helpful to others as they engage in making schools more effective for all
children.
SMH
1992
|